A coalition of community-based civic and environmental groups 
opposed to the commercial encroachment of Flushing Meadows-Corona Park.
SAVE FLUSHING MEADOWS-CORONA PARK!
  • Home
  • Triple Threat
  • Our Elected Officials
  • Press/Media
  • Blog
  • About Us

No soccer stadium!

2/2/2013

 
Dear Editor [Queens Chronicle]:

If small businesses are supporting Major Soccer League’s attempt to construct a stadium in Flushing Meadows Corona Park, they must have gotten intoxicated on the snake oil MLS has been pouring on the public (“MLS promotes small biz support,” Jan. 24, multiple editions).

People who watch games go home afterwards. They do not stop at small retail shops on Northern Boulevard to buy a pair of socks.

For years, multimillionaire private for-profit sports club owners have been blindsiding taxpayers in New York City and elsewhere, aided and abetted by inept politicians, claiming their businesses make important contributions to the municipality’s economy. There is no fiscal justification for the claim. Instead there is often a raid on the public treasury, along with enormous subsidies and perks.

Sports activities in New York City do not account for more than seven-tenths of 1 percent of the city’s gross economy, an amount of money that could be equated with the tip one gives the youngster who delivers your groceries. It does not put more police or firefighters on the streets or build more classrooms or affordable housing.

In his article “Play Ball or Else,” in the August 2005 Readers’ Digest, Michael Crowley notes that economist Allen Sanderson of The University of Chicago said, “Instead of attracting new money, stadium events just move money around that was already headed for the city coffers.”

If money is to be made from a stadium, it will go into the pockets of the ballclub owner and not the taxpayers, who in the case of MLS would lose parkland and add to the further desecration of the park.

Landscape architect Charles Birnbaum, the coordinator of the National Park Service Historic Landscape Initiative, wrote in Preservation magazine that open space in America’s parks is being wiped out by new structures and parking lots, as municipal officials tend to see such space as a void that must be filled.

But, he said, park users themselves aren’t demanding change. Two decades of surveys say that between 70 and 80 percent of American park users visit them specifically for passive reflective experiences, not for entertainment.

Birnbaum asks, “When was it decided that strolling in dappled shade under a canopy of trees or roaming a sloping lawn is not sufficient experience in its own right? When did we stop valuing the sound of running water, the humanizing scale and tactile marvels of nature? Who still appreciates historic moss-covered walls and paths or a landscape designer’s choice of plants and ornaments?”

His comments should be mandatory reading for all persons seeking public office — particularly people like state Sen. Jose Peralta, who does not view parkland as parkland, but as open space to be sold to the highest bidder, the public be damned. This belief is so obnoxious that in my opinion it makes him unworthy of holding public office.

Benjamin M. Haber
Flushing

Comments are closed.

    Save FMCP

    We are dedicated to stopping private development of Queens' flagship public park.

    Archives

    June 2017
    July 2015
    April 2015
    August 2014
    July 2014
    February 2014
    October 2013
    September 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013

    Categories

    All
    Al Centola
    Alex Rosa
    Alienation Of Parkland
    Andrew Hevesi
    Aqueduct
    Arboricide
    Ben Haber
    Berm
    Bill Deblasio
    Borough Board
    Borough President
    Casino
    Central Park
    Citifield
    City Club
    City Council
    City Planning Commission
    College Point
    Comments
    Committee
    Community Boards
    Construction
    Contamination
    Daniel Zausner
    Deis
    Disney
    Editorial
    Eminent Domain
    Fairness Coalition
    Flooding
    Flushing Meadows
    Flushing Meadows Corona Park
    Flushing Meadows-Corona Park
    Flushing River
    Francisco Moya
    Gambling
    Garages
    Geoffrey Croft
    Helen Marshall
    History
    Jobs
    Joe Lhota
    Jose Peralta
    Joseph Ardizzone
    Julissa Ferreras
    Landmarks Preservation Commission
    Lawsuit
    Major League Soccer
    Mall
    Melinda Katz
    Mets
    New Yorkers For Parks
    Nyc Park Advocates
    Parks Committee
    Pat Dolan
    Paul Graziano
    Peter Vallone
    Phil Konigsberg
    Pool Of Industry
    Power Plant
    Press Conference
    Public Hearing
    Public-private Partnership
    Public Use
    Queens Chronicle
    Queens Civic Congress
    Queens Housing Coalition
    Queens Museum
    Queens Preservation Council
    Rally
    Restoration
    Robert Loscalzo
    Shop Architects
    Soccer
    Stadium
    Sterling/related
    Tennis Center
    Testify
    The City Club Of New York
    Tony Avella
    Traffic
    Trees
    Ulurp
    Usta
    Vote
    Water Table
    Willets Point
    World's Fair

    RSS Feed