After her public hearing, at which there were 20 speakers in opposition and just 2 in favor, and prior opposition from the overwhelming majority of the combined memberships of community boards 3 and 7, Borough President Helen Marshall has APPROVED the 1.4 million square foot Mets mall to be constructed on mapped parkland in Flushing Meadows Corona Park.

The City Planning Commission public hearing is next Wednesday, July 10, on a calendar with other items. The entire session begins at 9:00AM, but according to the CPC calendar the Mets mall hearing "is not likely to begin before 11:30AM".

On Monday April 8th, the Queens Borough Board will vote on the USTA application. However, the Queens Borough Board has not held any public hearing on this application. Council members who would vote as Queens Borough Board members have no Borough Board record on which to rely, or to base their decision. Moreover, our own interpretation of the ULURP rules is that a Borough Board may ONLY submit a recommendation to City Planning Commission if the Borough Board first holds a public hearing. In the alternative, a Borough Board may elect to waive its right to submit a recommendation.
The relevant ULURP rule is here (Section 2-05).

As we interpret it, the first sentence sets forth two clear alternatives: "… an affected borough board may conduct a public hearing on an application AND submit a written recommendation on such application or any community board recommendations" OR "waive the right to submit a recommendation to the Commission" (emphases added). The presence of the word "and" in the first quoted section indicates that the two actions (conducting a public hearing AND submitting a written recommendation) go together. There is no authorization to submit a recommendation without holding the public hearing.

Via telephone last Friday, staff of the Office of the Queens Borough President stated that it is not required that the Borough Board hold a public hearing -- that the Borough Board "may" do so, but is not obligated. It was then pointed out that the very same text that says that they "may" hold a hearing continues "and submit a recommendation" to CPC -- in other words, that both events (the hearing and the recommendation) are connected. The word "AND" means that you do one, AND the other. You cannot split off the recommendation from the hearing (e.g., do the former but not the latter). They responded that it's always done this way, and that we should speak w/counsel to QBP, Hugh Weinberg.

That Council members who are on the Borough Board have heard nothing whatsoever directly from the public, and there is NO RECORD within the Borough Board -- other than USTA's presentation -- is a basis for any Borough Board vote. Even if the ULURP rules do not require a public hearing (and we believe they obviously do), there is no dispute that the rules allow the Borough Board to hold a public hearing -- and the Borough Board is not doing so. That amounts to a pointless exclusion of the public from Borough Board decision-making.

We are aware that, when a Borough Board authorizes disposition of City-owner property under City Charter section 384(b)(4), there is no requirement for a public hearing. But what is happening in the case of USTA is different, as the Borough Board is getting involved under the ULURP process -- and the ULURP rules, unlike 384(b)(4), apparently require a public hearing prior to any recommendation. The Office of the Queens Borough President may be confusing the circumstances of 384(b)(4) with those of ULURP, to which different rules apply.

Hello all,

The Parks Department has made arrangements to name the trail around Willow Lake in Flushing Meadows Corona Park after our late friend and leader Pat Dolan - The Pat Dolan Trail.  Please join us 11:00am on April 21 at the Al Mauro Playground, located at Park Drive East and 73rd Terrace (east side of park, south of Jewel Avenue) for the dedication. 

As you know FMCP was one of Pat's many lifetime priorities and QCC and the FMCP Conservancy are thrilled that Parks has decided to honor her commitment and hard work.  Willow Lake is a wilderness area of the park.  I once spotted a grey tailed fox while walking with a park ranger along the trail. 

I hope for a great turnout of civic leaders, electeds and friends for this great tribute. 

By the way, there will be a cleanup and planting at the Al Mauro Playgound beginning at 9am until the dedication.  I have word that the spring weather will be spectacular.  Put on your coveralls and join in.  Please see the FMCP Conservancy flyer for additional details about the cleanup as well as Earth Day events on April 11 and a Bird Walk/Nature Walk at the Pat Dolan Trail with PArks Rangers, sponsired by FMCP Conservancy on April 28. 

I hope to see you all on April 10 at the Borough Presidents Candidates Forum at 7pm at the Maple Grove Center, 127-15 Kew Gardens Road, Kew Gardens.  All six candidates have confirmed and we are keeping in close contact with them. 

Rich Hellenbrecht, President
Queens Civic Congress

USTA Chief Operating Officer - Daniel  Zausner. The USTA refuses to make its proposal publicly available.

Chief-of-Staff to the Borough President Alex Rosa (L) and Queens Borough President Helen Marshall (R).

Save FMCP member Phil Konigsberg testifies.

SaveFMCP co-founder Ben Haber testifies.

SaveFMCP co-founder Robert Loscalzo testifies.